Sammy’s review:
The book Monster is about a 16 year-old boy named Steve Harmon, a young talented African American actor, who lives in Harlem, New York. He is forced into a situation which puts him on trial for murder. He is accused of being involved in a robbery which led to the death of the owner of a drugstore. He is suspected of acting as a lookout for James King, the other suspect accused in this case, and there is evidence to prove his innocence. Since he was suspected of being involved in a robbery which led to the death of a store owner, he is being charged with felony murder, this way result in a sentence of up to 25 years in prison.
No one really knows if Steve killed the owner of the drugstore. Steve himself is beginning to become confused about his fate and whether he took any part in the stickup. For example, once in the book, Steve claims he just was in there to grab some mints, but in another section, he says he was only a lookout and didn’t even touch Mr. Nesbitt.
As in all books, most people have a favourite character. In the book Monster, Steve Harmon seemed to jump out at me as a very well-rounded person and even from the first hundred pages, I was shocked that he was in this position. In other words, I think Steve should have never been on trial in the first place.
I liked reading this book because it not only showed how one’s life can turn bad in a matter of hours, but it showed how one normal kid, against all odds, fought through to claim his rights. I disliked this book because, at times, the author repeated a phrase or idea to the point where it was slightly boring. I also found the fact that it is written like a script hard to comprehend. On a scale of one to ten, I would rate this book a six.
Monster is an interesting and exciting book for people who enjoy genres of crime, law, mystery, and drama, or other Walter Dean Myers novels.
Annelise’s review:
Monster, by Walter Dean Myers, is a realistic story about 16 year old Steve Harmon. The story is based on Steve being accused of being involved in a murder that could potentially put him in jail. Throughout the book Steve gets judged because he is a young black man. This story showed me his perspective of being a young black man on trial. This dreadful experience makes him feel like he is in a movie, so he writes a movie script. This my favourite element of the book. With the book in a movie format, it changes your perspective of his case, his life, and his feeling because it made me feel like I was in the movie and getting hurt by racism like Steve.
I like this book a lot because it made me realize how much discrimination went on when this true story took place. For example when Steve says “ I’ve never seen my father cry before. I hated his face. What did I do? Anybody can walk in a drugstore and look around” he got accused of felony murder because he is black. It also made me feel what pain and emotions Steve felt. You will like this book if you are curious about what really happens in jail and if you like a slow but emotional book.
Dawn’s review:
Monster is about a boy named Steve Harmon. He struggled with prejudice, specifically racism. In court it was a struggle. Steve Harmon’s lawyer, Miss O’Brien, was telling Steve that he had a slim chance to be acquitted. She told him how the court goes through things like this very often and she says they start to prejudge based on their ethnicity. She says that being a 16 year old black boy, to the court, is all the evidence that they need to prove him guilty. He was sent to jail accused of murder. He supposedly robbed a drug store with some kids in his neighbourhood. Steve writes in his journal and expresses what he feels. He also writes all that is happening as a movie script because he does not know what else to do and it keeps him sane.
I would give Monster two and a half stars out of five. It was very repetitive in places. The hearings in the court were boring when one person would talk and talk for a very long time. It made me want to skip their speeches. The better parts were when Steve would write in his journal. He would write what he was feeling and what he wrote was not boring at all. He would, in a way, pour his heart out. There was so much suffering, pain, and fear. You could really tell who he was when he wrote in his journal rather than when he was in court, hardly saying anything, feeling intimidated.
My favourite character was Steve Harmon. Even though lots of people around him were not that great he tried to stay true to himself and stay who he is. In part of the book Steve tries to get to know his lawyer, Miss O’Brien. He wants to convince her that he is not guilty and show her how he really is. He asks simple questions like “what are you doing this weekend?” Steve is very resourceful . He makes a play in his notebook while he is in JAIL! Steve is also insecure. He is letting someone call him monster and he also says it’s true. Steve is very scared and misses his family very much while he is in court and I think that he is not trying to win the case for himself but for his family. “ I raised my hand anyway and waved to him. I also wanted to tell Jerry that I loved him. I also wanted to tell him that my heart was not rejoicing and i was not singing praises.” When his mom visits, “I told her yes and tried to smile with her. Her eyes were smiling but her voice cracked. In a way I think she was mourning over me as if I were dead.” He just wanted to get “away from this place.”
If you like books that take weird turns and do things you don’t think will happen or that are very sad, realistic books then you would enjoy this book. If you enjoy a VERY light read than this is not your book! If you like every little thing to be detailed (in court) then read this.
Filed under: Lit Circles, Student Reviews | Tagged: Book Reviews, crime/law, racism, realist | Leave a Comment »